We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
Potato salad is a staple of Southern cuisine, especially for summertime cookouts. And while recipes vary, here are the basics: creamy mayo and/or mustard, chopped hard-boiled eggs, and tender chunks of boiled potatoes. From there, the possibilities are endless, but chopped onion and celery are almost always in the mix. Green bell peppers, pickle relish, and pickles are all very common add-ins to every classic Southern potato salad recipe. But one of the absolute best ways Southerners like to give potato salad a bold new twist without losing that traditional charm is to add a little extra spice.
In the South, recipes are often heirlooms—handed down as a unique way to prepare classic recipes. That means any tweaks, especially spicy ones, are made thoughtfully. Folks don’t overhaul what works; they enhance it. If the potato salad you grew up with is heavy on sweetness (thanks to sweet relish or sugar), a little heat can help balance it while adding tons of flavor. If your base is tangy or vinegary, spice can add depth. The beauty of potato salad (even store-bought potato salad) is that it starts with a familiar foundation. From there, it’s all about personal taste and preference. If you’re looking to keep things fresh, try diced jalapeños or serrano peppers for a bright, peppery kick. Start small (up to half a pepper) and remove the seeds for less heat. But if keeping things very Southern is your thing, add the perfect spicy zing with one of these two ingredients.
Dried spices fit right into this choose-your-own-adventure with potato salad
If you’re not opting for fresh pepper add-ins, there are two main paths to adding heat: hot sauce or dried spice blends. For a classic 2-pound potato salad (about 6–8 servings), start with 2 teaspoons of a vinegar-based grocery store hot sauce — something with a little tang, like Crystal, Tabasco, or Texas Pete. Stir it into your mayo or dressing before adding the potatoes, not after, so it blends evenly. Taste and adjust in small increments — usually no more than ½ teaspoon at a time — until you hit the right balance.
If you prefer a more layered flavor, a dry spice mix works beautifully. You can use a ready-made Cajun seasoning or make your own Cajun spice mix using 1 teaspoon of smoked paprika, ½ teaspoon garlic powder, ¼ teaspoon black pepper, a pinch of dried oregano or thyme, and ¼ teaspoon cayenne pepper, or more. Use about 1½ teaspoons of this blend per 2 pounds of potatoes, and don’t forget to mix it in with the dressing. Also, remember, dried Cajun spice is not only hot, but it’s pretty. That’s why Southerners like to sprinkle it right on top.
Here’s one more tip: Make it the night before — that way, the spice will mellow and settle into the potato salad. Whether your favorite side dish leans creamy, tangy, or somewhere in between, the right amount of heat will give any potato salad main-dish energy — so double that batch and don’t look back, y’all.
